It was bound to happen. Recently Kai peppered me with a lot of questions about how exactly this Santa Claus fellow could be real when the story just didn’t add up. When he finally came out with “Is Santa real?” I just couldn’t lie to the kid. Sure, I tried to dance around it. But then he asked, “Is he real like Superman and Batman are real?”
“I guess you could put it that way, yes.”
“Oh, so he’s not real,” he replied.
“That’s also a good way to put it.” Then Jade assured him that the presents are real, so he was totally cool with our conversation.
For those of you who don’t know, we don’t preach Santaism in our home. Even before we had kids, Bell and I agreed that we would not affirmatively lie to our children about Santa Claus.* Of course, in their minglings with peers on the playground and in school, inevitably they would hear tell of The Man, and if they believed these stories, that was okay. However, we refused to go out of our way to craft a little white lie, then build it up with other lies, only to have to tell them the truth later on and expose ourselves as, um, liars. It just wasn’t the type of role modeling we had envisioned for our kids. Why set your own pants on fire?
With Jade, this turned out not to be a problem because she never believed in Santa Claus in the first place. In fact, for several years she was outright hostile about The Man/The Myth, and we would have to direct her away from Santa’s House at the mall and depart the annual Christmas musical when He arrived in order to avoid a confrontation. Around this time every year, we told her that she must not speak of The Truth to her friends. We told her that some kids believe in Santa and it was not her job to shatter that illusion, and it would probably upset them. Plus, it was up to the parents to decide the proper time to be exposed in their lies. (Okay, okay, I’m being snarky here, and surely I have offended some of you Santa-ists, for which I sort of apologize.)
Annnnywho, after my conversation with Kai, as with Jade, I specifically told him that even though Santa isn’t real, most children believe he is and so he was not to tell them otherwise.
The next morning at school as the kids sat in circle time, Kai raised his hand. “Miss J? Santa Claus isn’t real.”
He couldn’t just pull one or two kids aside and share his secret under the monkey bars; no, he had to wait until 23 kids ranging in age from 4 to 6 (Santa’s primary target market!) were gathered. Hey everyone! Can I have your attention, please? There’s a rumor going ‘round and I’d like to clear it up once and for all: Santa’s not real! Any questions? Thank you, and Merry Christmas!
The teacher apparently came back with, “Yes he is.” [Good one!] But that was not the end of it. Many kids went home to their parents and told them what Kai had said, and apparently several cried. This pissed off the parents, who complained to the proprietress, who told the teacher to talk to us about it. So now we are the Black Sheep of Montessori. How awesome is that?
Jade pointed out that we are probably no longer welcome at the eleventy-three upcoming birthday parties for which we just received invitations. I don’t know many of the other parents (since Bell is usually the one to drop off and pick up Kai), but I can see it now—we will walk in to a party and suddenly a silence will fall over the room. Then people will look down at the floor or into their drinks, slowly dispersing like we’re carrying something contagious (like, THE TRUTH!) Never in my wildest imaginings did I think I’d be so self-conscious about saying, “Hi, I’m Kai’s mom!”
Incidentally, Kai felt really bad about all this. He asked if he should apologize to his teacher, then he started crying and said, “I shouldn’t have asked you the question!”
“You mean about apologizing to Miss J?”
“No, the question about whether Santa was real. I shouldn’t have asked you that, then the other kids wouldn’t have cried,” he said. Oh, my little truth-seeker, no! You should never be afraid to ask a question (because as my auto shop teacher once said, “The only stupid question is the unasked one”) I explained that the problem was not in asking the question but in sharing the answer with his friends after we had told him not to.
Remember that episode of "The Simpsons" where Maggie gets sent to school at the Ayn Rand School for Tots? Sigh. If Kai attended the Ayn Rand School for Tots, this would not be happening.
__________
*My parents never made a big deal of Santa, taking the same approach
Bell and I have taken, although probably for different reasons. My mom,
who was very religious, objected to anything in pop culture that
smacked of the mystical or magical. Thus, she prohibited us from
watching “Bewitched,” and “I Dream of Jeannie,” and she wasn't even keen on "The Flying Nun" (and she had been in the convent! Isn't that just wrong?) She banned the Ouija
Board from our slumber parties and refused to even play along with predicting her day based on the signs of the Zodiac. No way was she going to trumpet the
story of some fat guy with flying reindeer. I think she wanted to make
sure we used all our faith for the things that (she believed) mattered
most. But even without The Myth of Santa, Christmas has always been one
of my favorite holidays. The only time it lacked the “magic” you
Santa-ists wax on about was the year my dad was away and my mom, in
some sort of Jews-for-Jesus experiment gone awry, hung a giant star of
David in the window and decorated it with silver garland and a picture
of a manger scene in the middle. Oh yes, and remember The Year They Stole My Vanity?
Not so magical, that one. But I can’t blame the lack of belief in
Santa. My parents bought the goods, and my parents took them away.
Recent Comments